Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor

The Pro Football Reference Hall of Fame Monitor (HOFm) is a metric designed to estimate a player's chances of making the Pro Football Hall of Fame using AV, Pro Bowls, All-Pros, championships, and various stat milestones. The players listed below are the top 250 HOFm-rated players who played QB starting in 1955 or later for at least 50 career games. A score of 100 is around the average modern-era inductee.

All HOFm Positions: QB  RB  WR  TE  G  T  C  DT  DE  ILB  OLB  DB  K  P

QB HOFm Leaders

QB HOFm Leaders Table
Misc Games Passing
Player HOFm Chmp AP1 PB St From To CarAV G GS Cmp Att Yds TD Lng Int Sk Yds
Peyton Manning258.00271417199820151772662656125938071940539862513031953
Tom Brady 243.44631418200020191762852836377998874571541991795003129
Brett Favre 178.841311191991201015630229863001016971838508993365253487
Johnny Unitas 160.343510141956197311421118528305186402392908925374590
Joe Montana153.4543812197919941231921643409539140551273961393132095
Aaron Rodgers 139.011281120052019142181174391360614694636493844482968
John Elway137.7820916198319981382342314123725051475300862265163785
Drew Brees137.611113182001201916627527468671016177416547982374072902
Fran Tarkenton117.2801918196119781502462393686646747003342892662742337
Dan Marino116.8503916198319991452422404967835861361420852522701930
Steve Young112.983379198519991351691432667414933124232971073582055
Average HOF QB101227131151921742994509837787255901972772064
Bart Starr97.5351413195619719119615718083149247181529113859533
Terry Bradshaw94.8241313197019831061681582025390127989212902103072694
Roger Staubach93.352068196919791041311141685295822700153911093132154
Philip Rivers92.4800814200420191452282244908759159271397841984452714
Dan Fouts91.8502614197319871221811713297560443040254812423192304
Ben Roethlisberger91.1820615200420191252182164651723056545363971915033320
Matt Ryan91.1201412200820191351891894460681751186321931473692446
Kurt Warner88.78124819982009961241162666407032344208851282601669
Ken Anderson 83.4901413197119861211921722654447532838197941603982875
Eli Manning83.4120414200420191182362344895811957023366992444112870
Ken Stabler 82.621141119701984941841462270379327938194882222812514
Joe Namath82.50115919651977941401291886376227663173912201091052
Sonny Jurgensen78.92115101957197410621814724334262322242559918994748
Bob Griese73.4522812196719801051611511926342925092192861722672318
Warren Moon72.7000915198420001192082033988682349325291872334583415
Len Dawson69.7422712195719751092111592136374128711239921831671423
Boomer Esiason67.7301412198419971061871732969520537920247861843182438
Russell Wilson 66.75106820122019108128128243637772973422780683472271
Roman Gabriel66.700141119621977991831572366449829444201931491681268
Rich Gannon66.70024819872004991571322533420628743180841043021689
Joe Theismann65.60112819741985871671242044360225206160841383402757
John Brodie65.2501212195719739920115824694491315482148322447380
Cam Newton65.230138201120191041251242371398029041182911082912199
Troy Aikman64.853061219892000971651652898471532942165901412591748
Steve McNair60.6800310199520071001611532733454431304174871192541567
Jack Kemp60.302278195719696912210514363073212181149418321187
John Hadl59.6711612196219771072241662363468733503244852681791514
Jim Kelly59.1001511198619961031601602874477935467237841753232427
Phil Simms57.502021119791993911641592576464733462199801574773418
Donovan McNabb56.2300611199920111071671613170537437276234911174102626
Carson Palmer56.0200312200420171081821813941630746247294911873402364
Jim Hart 55.350041319661984992011802593507634665209982472431936
Drew Bledsoe54.8910412199320061031941933839671744611251862064673135
Randall Cunningham54.680147198520011071611352429428929979207951344843537
Daryle Lamonica50.58225619631974741518812882601191541649313872636
Bert Jones49.7001161973198281102961430255118190124901012322020
Vinny Testaverde49.090021519872007972332143787670146233275892674172992
Jim Plunkett48.742001019711986861571441943370125882164991983803279
Joe Flacco48.381001220082019921711713670593240067218951413592554
Earl Morrall48.353227195619766825510213792689208091619814858487
Frank Ryan46.831035195819707712687109021331604214996111435
Brian Sipe46.43011819741983751251121944343923713154741492241889
Tony Romo 46.25004820042016961561272829433534183248851172481672
Norm Snead 45.8100412196119768617815922764353307971969425794744
Dave Krieg45.560031219801998972131753105531138147261801994943794
Mark Brunell45.201031119942011961931512761464032072184791083902395
Alex Smith45.050031320052018961661613082494134068193801014102324
Michael Vick44.8500472001201593143115180732172246413391883161879
Jeff Garcia42.900048199920098912511622643676255371619983181947
Trent Green42.70002719972008941201132266374028475162991142591621
Matthew Stafford42.540011020092019951491493559569641025256871343472242
Brad Johnson 42.28102819942008741771252668432629054166821222511616
Matt Hasselbeck 42.030031119992015882091603222533036638212871533602260
Daunte Culpepper39.93003519992009861051002016319924153149821062981696
Ron Jaworski39.820011019741989841881432187411728190179991643632826
Steve DeBerg39.260001119781998792061402874502434241196932042962469
Steve Grogan39.090001019751990901491351879359326886182762082471986
Craig Morton38.271001119651982822071442053378627908183951873732800
Kerry Collins38.140021119952011811981803487626140922208891963372230
Jim Everett37.530011019861997871581532841492334837203811752571885
Andy Dalton37.40003920112019811331332757444931594204861182781738
Jay Cutler 37.330011020062017871531533048492035133227931603222035
Joe Ferguson 36.520001119731990811861712369451929817196922093122710
Danny White36.1010161976198884166921761295021959155801322412083
Chris Chandler35.23002919882004771801522328400528484170941463802590
Greg Landry34.080016196819848014698127623001605298841033102453
Andrew Luck 33.93004520122018718686200032902367117187831741124
Charley Johnson 33.85001101961197580165124173733922441017090181118894
Mark Rypien33.3510251988200156104781466261318473115828897664
Don Meredith33.200037196019687210483117023081719913595111
Jim Harbaugh 33.150011019872000781771402305391826288129851173612132
Archie Manning32.950021119711984751511392011364223911125851733963092
Jim McMahon 32.652019198219965711997149225731814810087902261344
Billy Kilmer32.600011119611978751701241585298420495152961461581193
Jake Plummer32.350011019972006771431362484435029253161851612841735
Jeff Hostetler31.85201619851997561528313572338164309485712071158
Ken O'Brien31.7300271984199372129110211036022509412896983532654
Neil Lomax30.7500271981198871108101181731532277113693903622700
Steve Bartkowski30.500021019751986701291271932345624124156861443562956
Matt Schaub30.430027200420197015493214833482546713680911801245
Jim Zorn30.33000719761987761401061669314921115111821412131585
Doug Williams30.251006197819895688811240250716998100849384734
Ryan Fitzpatrick30.180001020052019751561392886478732886210981612851509
Trent Dilfer29.63101719942007511301131759317220518113831292631730
Jon Kitna29.33000819972011741411242677444229745169911653231987
Tommy Kramer29.03001719771990701291102012365124777159761582491586
Steve Beuerlein28.73101419882003691471021894332824046147881123322124
Bernie Kosar27.6810171985199667126108199433652330112497872731660
Jeff Blake27.4000181992200567119100182732412171113488992481550
Bobby Hebert27.15001719851996661181001839312121683135981241781255
Kirk Cousins 26.50002520122019629388210431462410715581711741315
Ryan Tannehill25.280017201220196310098203031972317614591812792097
Jay Schroeder25.1310181985199462118991426280820063114851082081600
Jeff George24.95000919902001651311242298396727602154851133582691
Lynn Dickey24.93000819711985651521111747312523322141951792972423
Aaron Brooks24.83000520002006659390167329632026112376922351454
Neil O'Donnell24.7300171991200359125100186532292169012089682591906
Jake Delhomme24.6800161999201159103961741293220975126801011681267
David Garrard24.5000152002201061867614062281160038975541791115
Derek Carr24.28003620142019559494212033132279314387621711042
Dan Pastorini24.05101919711983601401171556305518515103851612462229
Marc Bulger23.90002820022009579695196931712281412280932541863
Kordell Stewart23.73001619952005591258713162358147467790841701048
Richard Todd23.55000719761985621191081610296720610124871612642127
Dak Prescott 23.350024201620195664641363207115778979036136826
Gus Frerotte21.9500151994200856147931699310621291114991062071328
Milt Plum21.6000271957196952129103130624191753612292127112
Bill Nelsen 21.03001519631972549074963190514165988710150494
Jameis Winston20.93001520152019547270156325481973712171881691075
Brian Griese20.55101519982008539383175227961944011988991931326
Chad Pennington20.0500052000201055898116322471178231028064162965
Doug Flutie19.700014198620055192661177215114715868468107687
Wade Wilson19.631014198119985112569139124281728399751022171508
Chris Miller19.330017198719995198921580289219320123891022091527
Bill Kenney19.280017198019885110677133024301727710584861951487
Stan Humphries18.5300061989199750888114312516171918999841441182
Nick Foles18.35101320122019295848105116981190171833597661
Jared Goff17.430023201620194154541166186914219879442106787
Scott Mitchell 17.080005199120014999711301234615692959181155882
Elvis Grbac16.9810141994200146105701446244516774998681129907
Gary Danielson16.68000419761988481016011051932137648187781831446
Matt Cassel16.430016200520184510881157826831750810479822101157
Colin Kaepernick16.4300042011201645695810111692122717280301711060
Bill Munson16.380006196419794810766107019821289684958074535
Jason Campbell15.8500052006201447907915192518167718784601701096
Rodney Peete15.60000719892004461048713442346163387693922441372
Carson Wentz 15.031014201620194256561311205514191977335129807
Blake Bortles 14.73000520142019447873156226341764910390751951158
Marcus Mariota14.580004201520194463611110176513207767544155992
Mike Tomczak14.53100419851999441857312482337160798885106114809
Sam Bradford 14.35000520102018448383185529671944910380611961371
David Carr14.3300052002201244947913532267144526581712671564
Tyrod Taylor 14.3310132011201941704683913629562548420142774
Mike Livingston14.131015196819794391759121751112955693831521392
Tony Banks13.6810051996200542967812782356153157785732271432
Don Majkowski13.4800141987199639905710561905127006679671801058
Erik Kramer13.080003198719994183671317229915337928579122788
Kyle Orton12.90000520052014418782161327121803710187691651016
Bob Berry 12.8800141965197538785266111739197648864131927
Bubby Brister12.8820041986200041997512072212144458190781931625
Mike Phipps12.53000519701981401197188617991050655801081721514
Josh McCown12.40000520022019401027615842633177319880822351563
James Harris12.2000141969197938834160711498136458059101874
Robert Griffin III12.0800132012201936524179112549229438828128875
Vince Young12.000024200620113360507551304896446735183449
Jay Fiedler11.950004199520053976601008171711844697466114734
Josh Freeman 11.730004200920153862611179204813873819568112690
Tony Eason11.600003198319903690519111564111426190511771350
Eric Hipple11.3800041980198938102578301546107115594701601188
Tom Tupa11.201111198820042922013259504343012772547372
Bobby Douglass 10.75000419691978379153507117864933685641801335
David Woodley10.600003198019853458536871300855848806384631
Pat Haden10.5300141976198133655573113639296526860115888
Steve Bono10.2010121985199932884293417011043962784276565
Marc Wilson10.052005198019903512660108520811439186921022101510
Mark Sanchez9.7300042009201834797313142320153578674891681090
Vince Ferragamo9.6800041977198632755390216151133676859194770
Case Keenum9.550004201220193467621304209114368756947120900
Charlie Batch8.93100419982012338155908160411085619852161890
Byron Leftwich8.9010032003201233605093016051053258844292452
Rick Mirer 8.4500051993200332806810882043119695060761991038
Mike Pagel7.65000419821993301325475615099414498063115837
Joey Harrington7.450006200220073081761424253814693798685124770
Tim Couch7.3000031999200330625910251714111316479671661119
Vince Evans7.03000219771995291003970413909485528974118904
Joe Kapp6.88001419671970235148449918591140856455429
Steve Fuller6.80100219791986299042605106671562877411521048
Bob Avellini6.5300031975198428735056011107111337569110961
Tom Flores6.181016196019693910668838171511959939392111
Mark Malone 6.1500051980198927735483916481017560638186671
Jack Concannon6.130003196419752790455601110627036936350401
Dave Brown6.080003199220012773608921634102484471581811005
Jim Ninowski5.9010031958196927893151310487133348467111
Chad Henne5.800003200820182768531161195912960588163149938
Virgil Carter 5.73000219681976265230425785506329903144343
Steve Spurrier5.5000031967197626106385971151687840816082634
Gary Cuozzo5.380004196319722682405841182740243725555401
John Friesz5.380001199020002669387451364869945814274487
Derek Anderson 5.3500132006201823784990916741087860786481563
Rex Grossman5.2500032003201223544786315621023256646092698
Billy Joe Tolliver5.25000319891999267947891170710760598264125877
Steve Pelluer4.45000219841990246530548974687029843981570
Randy Johnson4.430003196619762475496471286832951829072602
Tommy Maddox4.301002199220052492366861200808748725494541
Steve Ramsey4.030002197019762354314569216437357658110792
Brian Hoyer3.8810032009201923693887314771027452813486618
Jack Trudeau3.83000319861995236749873164410243428469103717
Gary Hogeboom3.7000021980198922793774313259436497260118890
Tarvaris Jackson 3.201002200620152159346401073726339713590546
Craig Erickson2.950002199219972152365911092762541713882535
Bob Lee 2.88000219691980217730368730503430634093805
Jeff Kemp2.78000119811991219629479916623039664068469
Kent Graham2.7500011992200121813869413397801398733100679
Scott Hunter2.70000419711979206442335748475623823858458
Steve Walsh2.650002198919992080387131317787540585040274
King Hill2.630001195819692012329429881555337927100
David Whitehurst2.43000219771983205437504980620528785199738
Dennis Shaw2.0300031970197519503748992463473575681241072
Damon Huard1.95100119982008196427574946630333782694612
Matt Moore1.931001200720191955326451074759749663687606
Dave Lewis1.6001001970197313560614570180422
Marty Domres1.35000219691977199032399809490427805079588
Don Strock1.280000197419881816722443779534945674237320
Pete Beathard1.2000031964197326110355751282817643868441353
Kyle Boller1.0500042003201117674786115198931487754123802
Terrelle Pryor1.0000022011201817513017531119949731232204
Dick Shiner0.93000219641974179929354736480136804346341
Scott Brunner0.820002198019851773305121046645729625471518
Cliff Stoudt0.60000119801989166620359684450623724376494
Dave Wilson0.550002198119881653315511039698736635599824
Joe Pisarcik0.450002197719841661304258985552248248112845
Blaine Gabbert0.2800022011201816564884214989063488047138916
Ty Detmer 0.08000219932003155425546946635134573567386
Frank Reich0.030001198519981511820508932607540633668503
Steve Dils-0.030001197919881510627504972581627683280575
Matt Cavanaugh-0.132001197919911511219305579433228753060462
Paul McDonald-0.23000119801986158521411767526924643778521
Seneca Wallace-0.30000120052013146422468788494731901959339
David Archer-0.70000219841989145523336661433718653089642
Jack Thompson-0.85000119791984135121449845531533804585695
Pat Ryan-0.930001197819911314519364657432031503550342
Ralph Guglielmi -1.150001195519631366272926264119248052
Joe Reed-1.33000119721979125019225513282518653159420
Steve Tensi-1.35000319651970205634369862555843794635243
Turk Schonert-1.43000019811989127212311504378811712064536
Matt Robinson-1.48000119771982126920244523351918773859470
John Roach-1.632001195619641264231824132765246237
Ray Lucas-1.65000119962002125515280483302918771729183
Todd Collins-2.18000119952010115021391701454722952467447
Gifford Nielsen-2.33000119781983105514273498325520482247354
John Reaves-2.33000019721987105117286616361717773463505
Gary Huff-2.40000319731978105728392788432916735082812
George Mira-2.530000196419711060814834621101979201087
Kellen Clemens-2.63000220062017106421350638405316812166401
Gary Wood-2.7300001964196910639186400257514702300
Don Horn-2.75100119671974105715232465336920893625217
Norris Weese-2.80000019761979957714325118877501436240
Tony Adams-3.0000001975198795310212408273312632759447
Jamie Martin -3.380000199620078538355541381420832136230